Peer Review and Critique

You will also be graded on your helpfulness to your classmate.  Submit a page with the title and author of the paper you critique, as well as your own name.  Address issues such as

• What you like about the paper,
• Clarity, grammar, punctuation, spelling,
• Is the topic too broad or too narrow, or too deep or too shallow?
• Organization and flow
• Is the science correct?
• Are references and citations done completely and correctly?
• Quality of the abstract, introduction, and conclusion

You may write directly on the draft of the paper as well (that is, mark it up).  Be as helpful as you can.  Turn your critique and the draft back to the author in class on Oct. 26.

Original author: you will need to turn in the rough draft and the critique from your colleague together with the final draft.